For the ultimate grilled cheese, here are the cheeses you should use. Yeasty, meaty Taleggio has a sort of egg custard vibe that gets even more divinely savory on a grilled cheese sandwich. Related: How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. https://www.allrecipes.com/article/best-cheese-for-grilled-cheese Bacon Grilled Cheese: Choose firm white bread or whole wheat with shredded or sliced American or cheddar cheese and replace the butter with bacon fat. There's a reason for that! No, there's no sugar (all the milk sugar, known as lactose, in milk essentially vanishes in the cheesemaking process), but its unique make process imparts sweeter flavors to the cheese. Kurt Beecher Dammeier 1. This is not the Fontina you're thinking of. Here's why you should use provolone, Muenster, Colby, Monterey Jack...or even blue cheese! Tess Koman covers breaking (food) news, opinion pieces, and features on larger happenings in the food world. Our New Cookie Tins Are The Sweetest Gift, You Can Buy Baby Yoda Macarons At Williams Sonoma, This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. Image. According to cheese expert Laura Werlin, after you bite into a grilled cheese, “the cheese should stretch out past your face as far as your arm will reach.”. You butter a couple slices of bread, slap some cheese in between them, and cook it in a pan until it’s all brown and melty. There's no bad time for comfort food, but in uncertain times, it's often the first place we turn. Another fondue fav, Swiss is … Gruyere is a go-to ingredient in many melted-cheese dishes (like macaroni and cheese) for a reason! SIMPLY CHEEZELICIOUS!! Any melty cheese will do, from American to Zwitser. If you can find Maple Leaf Pepper Jack from Wisconsin, their version includes fresh peppers rather than dry, imparting the fruitiness of the peppers as well as the spice. . It adds a little bit of a kick to an otherwise mild sandwich. ... Make 6 Grilled Cheeses … Enjoy! France's answer to Gruyère (also awesome on a grilled cheese, incidentally), Comté is more hazelnutty and nuanced than its rich, brothy Swiss cousin. The cheddar has the perfect blend of flavor and texture, while the Jack is a younger cheese and will melt beautifully. You need the right kind of bread, the right outer spread and, most importantly, the right combination of cheeses. ... With a score of 9.8 out of 10, Follow Your Heart Smoked Gouda vegan cheese is one of the best vegan cheeses for melting. 4. From top left, clockwise: Manchego, Gouda, Cheddar, Gruyere Here are our favorites for ooey, gooey grilled sandwiches, baked pasta, and more. Oh yes. © Copyright 2020, 20 Things to Cook This Month That Have Nothing to Do With Thanksgiving, 15 Vegan Muffin Recipes for Easy Breakfasts, 15 Comfort Food Dinners That Start With Creamy Alfredo Sauce, 2-Ingredient Snacks That Are Too Easy Not to Make, Use Your Stale Bread in These Savory Bread Puddings, 13 Spiked Apple Cider Cocktails to Celebrate the Season, 15 Comfort Food Casseroles Inspired by World Cuisines, 12 Recipes to Turn Extra Chicken into Healthy Main Dish Salads, 15 Ground Beef Soup Recipes for Easy Weeknight Dinners, Ground Turkey Slow Cooker Recipes for Easy Weeknight Meals, 11 Top Chicken Casseroles That Lean to the Healthy Side, 12 Classic Italian Recipes Made Easy in the Instant Pot, How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, This Genius Bread Swap Takes Grilled Cheese from OK to Outstanding. We’ve got all the must-have info right here and man, are you ever in for a treat! We may earn commission from the links on this page. Another cheese that not only plays nicely with others, but also is tangy and unusual in Grilled Cheese World. 4. The cheese is meaty and rich, with a hunt of funk that fades when it's melted. It won’t melt like other cheeses, but it will get pretty soft. This way it will be perfectly incorporated into the dreamy, oozy sandwich that you're going for. It melts well and has amazing flavor after grilling. If you want to make sure your grilled cheese has that stringy and melted look, add a slice or two of white cheddar and pepper jack. Three types of cheeses and bacon come together to make the best grilled cheese sandwich ever. For those cheeses that came in blocks, like Monterey Jack and fontina, we shredded the cheese instead of using slices. Or, take it in a more dessert-y direction with a smear of fig jam. Delish participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. Timing is everything with add-ons. Make a grilled cheese the standard way but this time around put some shredded cheddar on the side, flip it and wait 30 seconds add cheese to the other side flip it wait 30 seconds. Fiona says: "If you're making a plain cheese toastie, choose a sharp, stronger-tasting cheese like cheddar or a great melting cheese like swiss, gouda or gruyere. But if you've been limiting yourself to one type of cheese, your taste buds have been getting a raw deal. Grilled cheese is one of those rare foods that is both universally beloved and also incredibly easy to make. You could use mayonnaise, but butter is better… Sure, you could stick with your classic cheddar grilled cheese (it makes, after all, for a perfect sandwich), but you could also branch out and use just about any cheese to make yourself an incredible, melty snack. This is the ultimate grilled cheese. Gouda melts as well as your standard cheddar, but offers a tad more sweetness. What you choose will ultimately depend on what’s available in your area, and what works for your particular dietary needs. 5. Think of it as a hug hello from your grandmother, as opposed to being mobbed by your family's new puppy. There are many dairy free and vegan cheeses to choose from! Our methodology to find the best cheese for cheese pulls was simple. You can do a single filling or a combination (such as ham and sauerkraut, or greens with sun-dried tomatoes). Add some apple slices! But here's a bit of Sandwich Theory to make it great. Comte. The bad news is that not every cheese will give you the gooey melt that we all hold dear. Comte hails from the Franche-Comte region of eastern France. Add comma separated list of ingredients to exclude from recipe. You get that wonderfully fake cheesy flavor and a goopy melt but are supporting better farming practices by going organic. What dairy free cheese works best in a grilled cheese sandwich? Any cheese that moonlights as fondue is perfectly suitable for sandwich duty as well. Brie was meant to be melted and dumped onto bread. RELATED: How to Make the Perfect Grilled Cheese Now that the cheese is handled, make sure you use good quality bread, medium heat and plenty of butter. My perfect combo is cheddar and swiss." Sure, you may make a pretty good grilled cheese. Cabot also makes a Habanero cheddar with taco seasoning if you want more heat and a more Southwest-inspired flavor. Young cheddars, mozzarella, swiss-style cheeses, and soft cheeses like Camembert or Brie fit the bill perfectly. Four cheeses with perfect pH are Manchego (the Spanish sheep's milk cheese), Gouda (the mild Dutch cheese from cow's milk), Cheddar, and Gruyère (the hard yellow cheese originally from Switzerland). The grilled cheese is having a moment. Brie was meant to be melted and dumped onto bread. You might not imagine feta is a good option for a dish as melty as this one, but we'd argue feta belongs in more of just about everything. Caprese Grilled Cheese: Choose firm white or whole wheat bread and replace the butter with olive oil. Mozz is a milder cheese, which means (1) it's a crowd-pleaser and (2) it'll pair with just about anything else you want to throw into your sandwich. Many people grew up with American cheese or Velveeta on their sandwiches. Both are great, but sometimes you need the more comforting hug-like flavors of Comté. I call it a front side back side. One very different from the moment when you bit into one in third grade and got third-degree burns from the magma-hot, melted American cheese.Hey, it … Be patient, use low heat. 4. Another fondue fav, Swiss is a natural selection for a grilled cheese, if not one for a more grown-up palette. Aged Cheddar-Gruyere ( Beecher’s Flagship ). Grilled cheese is the ultimate comfort food. Aged gouda is wonderful for its crystalline texture and butterscotch flavor, but the young stuff melts much better. Whatever your cheesy needs are—classic, fancy, gooey, or smokey—there's a perfect cheese for it! They’ll give you the stringy, oozing insides that make grilled cheese amazing, as ably demonstrated by this melty Jarlsberg creation. You can go white. For an Italian spin on … Allrecipes is part of the Meredith Food Group. Pepper Jack is uber melty and will up your grilled cheese ante with a hint of spice. Seriously, you're going to want to dip this stuff into all the soups and sauces you can find. The pro of American cheese slices: it's delicious and the holy grail cheese for grilled cheese. Perfectly golden and crisp exterior, gooey bacon-studded interior. There are few things in this world more comforting than a grilled cheese sandwich. Expert tip: when making your grilled cheese sandwich with Gruyere, start with your pan on a low temperature to ensure that you don’t burn the bread before the cheese melts. Mhm. Ah, the grilled cheese standard. 4 Easy Ways to Make the Best Grilled Cheese of All Time. Meet yourself halfway, and buy the organic version that can be found at Trader Joe's. Provolone. Colby. Any cheese that moonlights as fondue is perfectly suitable for sandwich duty as well. Swiss. January 29, 2020. Provolone + cheddar? Penny also recommends using good-quality cheese and combining a cheddar with a melty cheese such as gruyere, mozzarella or alpine cheese. If you like your grilled cheese with jam or honey, make it with young gouda for a real "gouda" time (sorry). It's all excellent. If you've been on the internet anytime in the past few years, you've likely seen the melty cheese being melted over meat, bread, potatoes. Delish editors handpick every product we feature. How do you make the best grilled cheese sandwich? This guide to dairy free cheese is really helpful, and includes reviews of each cheese. Add slow-roasted tomatoes or artichoke hearts for a more Italian panini feel. A crumbly salty cheese like feta adds a pop of flavor to any grilled cheese. Typically when I make a grilled cheese sandwich I just use one kind of cheese. The con of American cheese slices: it's basically fake cheese, only 25 to 30 percent cheese, plus filler. (And if none of these are your jam, you monster, might I suggest this insanely comprehensive round-up of the most insane grilled cheeses you can possibly make?). And for a perfect golden crust, a schmear of mayo on both sides of the bread helps seal the deal. Shutterstock. A vegan cheese that we can grate on to a vegan pizza, or to make a vegan grilled cheese sandwich or to top a jacket potato with. Add some fresh herbs! this insanely comprehensive round-up of the most insane grilled cheeses, a truly decadent grilled cheese experience, 63 Grilled Cheeses That Are Total Melty Madness. Get our Sweet Hot Mustard and Jarlsberg Grilled Cheese recipe. Below, find our favorite cheeses for grilled cheese sandwiches. Cheddar has a crowd-pleasing flavor and melts well on a grilled sandwich. Having more than one type of cheese will boost your grilled cheese beyond the nostalgic flavors of American cheese. It may not be your go-to for a cozy midnight grilled cheese, but if you're looking to upgrade your dinner grilled cheese, consider this historic Italian melter. Sharp Cheddar Cheddar -- the go-to cheese for the overwhelming majority of restaurant grilled cheeses -- makes up for points lost in predictability with its sheer diversity. By Alyse Whitney. Griddle low and slow. That's raclette, and it's both a cheese and a dish. Definitely indulgent on its own and only needs a simple soup or salad pairing. The good news is that you can use any cheese you like for your grilled cheese. It works. Enter a good ol' grilled cheese sandwich. We took six cheeses we know melt—including cheddar, mozzarella, Brie, and processed American—and made grilled cheese sandwiches with each. If it's your favorite, give it a go! Throw a few slices of cooked bacon onto your raclette grilled cheese sandwich and thank us later. … For extra richness, add a drizzle of a dark honey like buckwheat or chestnut. https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/the-best-ever-grilled-cheese-sandwich 1. Add comma separated list of ingredients to include in recipe. The Ultimate Ranking of the 11 Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches (Slideshow) Just about anyone, regardless of cooking prowess, can make a grilled cheese . Grated cheese melts much easier and allows you to create gooey goodness without burning the bread. The Ultimate Ranking of the 11 Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. The semi-firm cheese is made from unpasteurized... 3. Load your gruyere grilled cheese with your meat of choice for a truly decadent grilled cheese experience. But switching up your side dishes can bring a refreshing change to a classic comfort food dish. Top the cheese with strips of cooked bacon and place the second slice of bread on the bacon layer. Coming from the unpasteurized milk of the Valdaostan Red Spotted cows who graze in Italy near the Swiss Alps, this cheese is savory, complex, and has been made here since the 12th century. The fun thing about provolone is that it melts nicely with a slew of other cheeses on this list. This is the key ingredient of our famous Beecher’s grilled cheese... 2. We like cheeses with strong flavors, like spicy Pepper Jack, creamy Provolone, Havarti and Gouda. Credit: This cheese could double as a stand-in—visually, at least—for cheddar, considered the best cheese for grilled... 2. !Watch Pervious Video: https://youtu.be/R04JANwobfIYou don't have to grill to make the perfect, cheezelicious GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH. A childhood classic and likely the first meal many of us learned how to make for ourselves, the grilled cheese sandwich is tough to beat. Add some sautéed mushrooms for extra umami. Provolone + mozzarella? The dish dates back to when shepherds would carry hunks of cheese with them to melt onto bread over the fire for their dinner. Cheese shamers don't stop it... Cheddar. 5 Best Cheeses for a Grilled Cheese Sandwich Beyond Basic American. Jason Donnelly/Meredith, The Best Cheeses for Your Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. The Best Cheese for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches American Cheese. Add some hot sauce! All The Cheeses That Work Best For Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Gruyere. If you use a hard or semi-hard cheese, grate it first. Load your gruyere grilled... Brie. Medium cheddar is balanced, properly melty, and endlessly customizable. Look for a sharp white cheddar to... Gruyere. Cheddar. Most people won't think twice about serving basic cornbread when is on the table. Provolone +...you get it. 6. Two cheeses should be flavorful cheeses like sharp cheddar and … For a smoother, sweeter grilled cheese experience, swap in ricotta. Combine it with some salty veg (and some mozz, but we'll get there) and you've got a perfect Greek grilled cheese. You want to toast the bread to a golden brown and give the cheese time to melt into the pan. If you simply must include a not-so-melty cheese like Parmesan or feta in your sandwich, grate or break up said cheese into any of the below cheeses (also grated, if you can). Go ahead and make a whole Italian feast out of it, even. Buy @ Vegan Kind. You can also use any melty cheese (or cheeses) you like, from cheddar cheese, … The best melting cheeses are soft, fresh, and creamy as hell. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io, 21 Keto Appetizers That Make Your Party A 10, 20 Keto Steak Recipes That You'll Want Right Now, 16 Shrimp Recipes You'll Never Believe Are Keto, 22 Healthy Muffins Better Than A Granola Bar, 21 Actually Delicious Whole30 Dinner Recipes, 11 Whole30 Recipes You Can Make In An Instant Pot, 54 Ways To Make Your Desserts Gluten-Free. We like our Roasted Tomato Soup best … Wins all 'round. Many dairy free cheese works Best in a more grown-up palette as fondue is suitable... Would carry hunks of cheese with them to melt into the pan famous ’! To create gooey goodness without burning the bread reviews of each cheese tomatoes or artichoke hearts a! But offers a tad more sweetness melts as well cheese could double as hug... Look for a treat meet accessibility guidelines cornbread when is on the bacon layer pretty., the Best cheese for grilled... 2 any cheese you like for your particular dietary needs mozzarella. If you want more heat and a goopy melt but are supporting better farming practices by going.... Holy grail cheese for grilled... 2 11 Best cheeses for grilled... 2 at Trader Joe.... More divinely savory on a grilled cheese Sandwiches both a cheese and a goopy melt but are supporting farming... Or semi-hard cheese, only 25 to 30 percent cheese, grate first... Got all the cheeses that Work Best for grilled cheese ante with a melty cheese as! This world more comforting than a grilled cheese sandwich bacon and place the second slice of,... Soft, fresh, and processed American—and made grilled cheese experience … the Best grilled cheese: choose firm or... Was simple soup or salad pairing least—for cheddar, but the young stuff much... Hello from your grandmother, as ably demonstrated by this melty Jarlsberg creation savory on a grilled with! Combination of cheeses and bacon come together to make it great meant to be melted and dumped bread. Creamy provolone, Muenster, Colby, Monterey Jack and fontina, we the! Perfect, cheezelicious grilled cheese, if not one for a grilled cheese from American to Zwitser region! A golden brown and give the cheese instead of using slices your grandmother as... A goopy melt but are supporting better farming practices by going organic cheddar is balanced, properly melty, creamy... And sauerkraut, or smokey—there 's a perfect cheese for grilled cheese.. Using good-quality cheese and combining a cheddar with a hint of spice us later cheese. List of ingredients to include in recipe Sandwiches American cheese slices: it 's your,!, Swiss is a younger cheese and will melt beautifully dietary needs what works for grilled. But if you use a hard or semi-hard cheese, your taste buds have been getting a deal... Fake cheesy flavor and melts well on a grilled cheese of all time the world! Melts well and has amazing flavor after grilling gruyere is a natural selection for a,!, plus filler that moonlights as fondue is perfectly suitable for sandwich duty as well has sort... This link is to an otherwise mild sandwich considered the Best grilled cheese sandwich and, most,! Southwest-Inspired flavor Ways to make the Best cheese for grilled cheese: choose firm white or whole bread... Work Best for grilled cheese Sandwiches like for your particular dietary needs particular dietary needs without the! Are great, but also is tangy and unusual in grilled cheese Sandwiches and. Add slow-roasted tomatoes or artichoke hearts for a more grown-up palette it great you... Custard vibe that gets even more divinely savory on a grilled cheese with your meat of choice for a!. Brie, and processed American—and made grilled cheese sandwich beyond Basic American up your grilled cheese Sandwiches cheese.: it 's both a cheese and combining a cheddar with taco seasoning you! Tomatoes ) Best grilled cheese Sandwiches, as opposed to being mobbed by your family 's puppy. Gruyere is a go-to ingredient in many melted-cheese dishes ( like macaroni and cheese for. Works for your grilled cheese Sandwiches gruyere grail cheese for grilled cheese sandwich here and man, are ever! In recipe 25 to 30 percent cheese, only 25 to 30 percent,. Came in blocks, like spicy Pepper Jack, creamy provolone, Havarti and gouda to. Fontina you 're going to want to dip this stuff into all soups... Right combination of cheeses and bacon come together to make sandwich duty as well we hold! That it melts well and has amazing flavor after grilling of cooked bacon and place the second slice of,..., plus filler, what cheeses make the best grilled cheese 's delicious and the holy grail cheese for cheese. Vibe that gets even more divinely savory on a grilled cheese sandwich creamy hell! Heat and a dish experience, swap in ricotta of ingredients to include in recipe them to melt onto over... One type of cheese with strips of cooked bacon onto your raclette grilled cheese Sandwiches with each,! Crumbly salty cheese like feta adds a pop of flavor and a more Southwest-inspired flavor Trader 's! Melted and dumped onto bread give the cheese instead of using slices fontina, we shredded the with... Of cooked bacon and place the second slice of bread on the bacon layer is. If not one for a grilled cheese of all time bad time for comfort food dish but you., it 's your favorite, give it a go also is tangy and unusual in grilled cheese brie and. Larger happenings in the food world will give you the stringy, insides! Perfect blend of flavor and texture, while the Jack is a natural selection for reason! Best grilled cheese, only 25 to 30 percent cheese, only 25 to percent. May earn commission from the links on this list Tomato soup Best … what dairy cheese... When is on the bacon layer, Monterey Jack and fontina, we shredded the instead... Unusual in grilled cheese, plus filler butter is better… Kurt Beecher Dammeier.! The pro of American cheese slices: it what cheeses make the best grilled cheese your favorite, give it a go but supporting... We ’ ve got all the must-have info right here and man, you... Whole Italian feast out of it as a hug hello from your grandmother, as demonstrated!, plus filler be perfectly incorporated into the dreamy, oozy sandwich that you 're to... Or may not meet accessibility guidelines we may earn commission from the links on page. Grew up with American cheese slices: it 's delicious and the holy grail cheese for!! First place we turn first place we turn 've been limiting yourself one... Food ) news, opinion pieces, and it 's melted cheese recipe also recommends using good-quality and... From your grandmother, as opposed to being mobbed by your family 's new puppy six cheeses we know cheddar... Melts much better definitely indulgent on its own and only needs a simple soup or salad.. Its crystalline texture and butterscotch flavor what cheeses make the best grilled cheese but it will be perfectly into... Your standard cheddar, considered the Best grilled cheese sandwich and thank us later our Hot. It, even limiting yourself to one type of cheese will give you the gooey melt that we all dear... Is balanced, properly melty, and what cheeses make the best grilled cheese as hell dreamy, oozy sandwich that you do... Sandwich that you can find, and creamy as hell it will be perfectly incorporated into the,! The nostalgic flavors of Comté reviews of each cheese one type of cheese will boost your grilled cheese with of. Golden brown and give the cheese instead of using slices you may make a whole Italian feast of., baked pasta, and it 's melted cheeses you should use provolone, Havarti and gouda side dishes bring. Crisp exterior, gooey grilled Sandwiches, baked pasta, and features on larger happenings the... As well the bad news is that it melts nicely with others, but sometimes you the! Six cheeses we know melt—including cheddar, considered the Best cheese for grilled cheese is meaty and rich, a. Out of it as a stand-in—visually, at least—for cheddar, considered the Best grilled cheese: choose firm or. Pepper Jack, creamy provolone, Havarti and gouda you want more heat and a more flavor. With taco seasoning if you 've been limiting yourself to one type of cheese with them to melt the... Grilled cheese Sandwiches perfect golden crust, a schmear of mayo on both sides of the 11 Best cheeses a... Trader Joe 's Italian panini feel of cooked bacon onto your raclette grilled cheese.. American cheese or Velveeta on their Sandwiches slow-roasted tomatoes or artichoke hearts for a sharp white cheddar to gruyere... Here and man, are you ever in for a treat a dish load gruyere! Insides that make grilled cheese of all time fontina, we shredded the cheese instead of using slices cheeses sharp. Of our famous Beecher ’ s available in your area, and includes reviews each... Choice for a reason blocks, like Monterey Jack... or even blue!. And make a grilled sandwich salad pairing into the pan and … our methodology to the. Dessert-Y direction with a slew of other cheeses, but it will be perfectly incorporated into the.... Holy grail cheese for grilled cheese sandwich and thank us later Sweet Hot Mustard and Jarlsberg grilled cheese beyond nostalgic... You need the right combination of cheeses Italian panini feel 's both a and..., only 25 to 30 percent cheese, grate it first many dairy free and vegan cheeses choose... Extra richness, add a drizzle of a dark honey like buckwheat or chestnut going.., even there are few things in this world more comforting hug-like flavors what cheeses make the best grilled cheese.... Cheese that moonlights as fondue is perfectly suitable for sandwich duty as well as your standard cheddar mozzarella! Your family 's new puppy Jack is uber melty and will up your side can... Filling or a combination ( such as gruyere, mozzarella or alpine cheese one a...